I have seen of punishment against broken

Numerology of birth, g, and as punishment, harm, broken of change between the solid figure of eight, it can make the original good horoscope configuration into bad;Also can make the original bad feng shui configuration becomes good, so the ancients have "of Yin and Yang five elements theory to deep to change" say....

Because of this, so the traditional life home all dare not ignored the crucial change, most of life, also will these changes give detail, such as the deep pool and big ocean child flat "three life will pass" "life", etc.;Can also have life, but the punishment harm to break the negative view, more is representative of the qing dynasty Chen Suan renew numerology covenant, with Ren Tieqiao pulp in micro drop day, especially the numerology covenant "with considerable length on the irrationality of" punishment against broken ", and thus to demonstrate "the punishment against broken" far-fetched unreasonable....

According to the basis of discourse to be sure they have but very reasonable, because they all stand in their positions to demonstrate their own ideas, or because they are different foothold, so will be completely different conclusions, this also is normal things.......

The problem is the two distinct arguments, we share should grasp how to choose?Personally, I think the complete abolition of "punishment against break" method is not desirable!Although Chen Suan, Ren Tieqiao's original intention is "in order to avoid chalking, but increase the difficulty of push when life", for starters, raw, g, and mixed together already enough, add "punishment against break" is indeed may "but increase the difficulty of push when life", but I think if only so he abolished "punishment against break" argument is very questionable.

Life in Ming dynasty, the theory of liu bowen "punishment and wear (harm) xi always" have also been Chen Suan references and indirect proof as Ren Tieqiao "punishment against break" is meaningless, because "drop days pulp" cloud: "in god to only heavy, punishment and wear xi always"....

But I do have different opinions, first of all, liu bowen of "punishment and wear xi always" can also be understood as "punishment and wear" strength weak and not to "life, g, and" par.Second Ren Tieqiao "punishment and wear xi always" is relative in terms of "rush" word, or to illustrate "punishment and wear" is far from being compared with the "go".So they are all standing in the power of "punishment and wear" and is not "born, g, and" come big or apparent this Angle to present arguments....

So power mild or very little "punishment against break" whether it should be completely abolished?Personally, I think the answer is no!Because "punishment against break" to mild, or at least have a secret information, in the practice of some slight not obvious information often easily ignored by us, so more should cause the attention of our forecasters, in reality there are many evil is in our imperceptibly quietly....

In all my experience is: if life in eight innings in or shipped "born, g, and", then "punishment against break" temporarily ignored the problem is not big, because "punishment against break" is not to give priority to melody;But if there is no obvious "born, g, and" only "punishment against break", is the "punishment against break" this signal cannot be ignored, since the "punishment against break" very likely evolution is given priority to melody, it is also under certain conditions of random strain....

I had only used in the prediction "punishment against break" come straight off life master, and the effect is also good practice for many times, so my experience is: when "blunt grams" apparent ignore the "punishment against break" problem is not big, while "go," is not obvious "punishment against break" the hidden information cannot be ignored, so as to avoid future "blessing when you come, curse and I do not know"....

I feel infinite amplification, of course, "the punishment against broken" thinking is not desirable, one is because "the punishment harm to break the" muscle after all can't with blunt g;Secondly because "punishment against break" a merger with blunt, deposit, its fulfillment is less more obvious than other forms, usually only when there is an other form is not so, "punishment against break" in order to have the opportunity to appear in performance....

Personal opinion, relied upon, exclusive, hard to avoid is wrong, all copyright, please do not reprint, for reference only, welcome to correct!